+1 (347) 907-1248

Mo-Fri 9am-6pm

140 Broadway 46th 4615,
New York, NY 10005

What is removal defense?

What is removal defense?

Welcome to our guide on removal defense, an essential aspect of immigration law that plays a vital role in protecting individuals facing the risk of deportation. In this article, we will explore the concept of removal defense, its significance, and the various strategies and options available to individuals fighting removal proceedings.

I. Introduction

What is removal defense?

Removal defense refers to the legal process of defending individuals who are facing removal proceedings initiated by the U.S. government. These proceedings aim to determine whether a person should be removed from the country due to immigration violations, criminal convictions, or other grounds of removability.

Importance of understanding removal defense

Understanding removal defense is crucial for anyone who may be subject to removal proceedings. It allows individuals to navigate the complex legal system, present a strong defense, and explore potential avenues for relief or protection from deportation.

Overview of the article

In this article, we will delve into the intricacies of removal defense, starting with an explanation of removal proceedings and the grounds for removal. We will then explore the role of removal defense and the importance of legal representation. Next, we will discuss the various forms of relief available and how to prepare for removal proceedings. We will also provide an overview of the court process and what happens after the proceedings. Finally, we will address some frequently asked questions related to removal defense.

II. Understanding Removal Proceedings

Removal proceedings, also known as deportation proceedings, are legal proceedings initiated by the U.S. government to determine an individual’s eligibility for removal from the country. These proceedings take place in immigration court before an immigration judge.

Definition of removal proceedings

Removal proceedings refer to the legal process through which the U.S. government seeks to deport non-U.S. citizens who are believed to be in violation of immigration laws or have committed certain offenses that make them removable from the country.

Reasons forinitiating removal proceedings

There are various reasons why removal proceedings may be initiated. Some common grounds for removal include:

  • Violation of immigration laws: This includes entering the country without proper authorization, overstaying a visa, or engaging in fraudulent activities related to immigration.
  • Criminal convictions: Individuals convicted of certain crimes, such as drug offenses, domestic violence, or crimes involving moral turpitude, may be subject to removal.
  • Security threats: Individuals who pose a threat to national security or have engaged in terrorism-related activities may be eligible for removal.
  • Immigration violations: Failing to comply with immigration regulations, such as working without proper authorization or failing to maintain valid immigration status, can lead to removal.

How removal proceedings work

Removal proceedings typically begin with the issuance of a Notice to Appear (NTA) by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). The NTA outlines the charges against the individual and sets a date for the initial hearing before an immigration judge.

During the proceedings, the individual has the right to present a defense, provide evidence, and make arguments against their removability. The government, represented by the DHS, bears the burden of proving the individual’s removability by clear and convincing evidence.

Role of immigration judges

Immigration judges play a crucial role in removal proceedings. They preside over the hearings, evaluate the evidence and arguments presented, and make decisions regarding the individual’s removability and eligibility for relief. Immigration judges are responsible for ensuring a fair and impartial process while upholding immigration laws.

III. Grounds for Removal

Common grounds for removal

There are various grounds on which an individual may be deemed removable from the United States. Some common grounds include:

  • Unlawful presence: Individuals who have overstayed their authorized period of stay or entered the country without inspection may be subject to removal.
  • Criminal convictions: Certain crimes, such as drug offenses, aggravated felonies, or crimes involving moral turpitude, can make an individual removable.
  • Visa violations: Violating the terms and conditions of a visa, such as working without authorization or engaging in unauthorized activities, can lead to removal.

Examples of removable offenses

Removable offenses can vary widely and may include crimes such as drug trafficking, domestic violence, fraud, or theft. The severity of the offense and the individual’s criminal history can impact the determination of removability.

Categories of removable individuals

Removability applies to both documented and undocumented individuals. It is important to note that even individuals with legal status, such as green card holders, can be subject to removal if they violate immigration laws or commit certain offenses.

Overview of the removal process

The removal process consists of several stages, including the initial hearing, individual merits hearing, and the judge’s decision. Throughout the process, individuals have the right to present a defense, challenge the government’s evidence, and apply for relief or protection from removal.

IV. The Role of Removal Defense

Definition and purpose of removal defense

Removal defense refers to the legal strategies and arguments presented to challenge an individual’s removability and seek relief from removal. The primary goal of removal defense is to prevent or delay deportation and explore options for remaining in the country lawfully.

Role of an immigration attorney

In removal proceedings, having an experienced immigration attorney is crucial. An immigration attorney can provide legal representation, guide individuals through the complex process, analyze the case for possible defenses and relief options, and present a strong defense strategy.

Building a defense strategy

A solid defense strategy involves thoroughly analyzing the individual’s case, identifying potential defenses, and gathering relevant evidence to support the defense. The defense strategy may include challenging the government’s evidence, proving eligibility for relief, or arguing against removability based on legal or procedural grounds.

Challenging removability

Challenging removability requires carefully examining the charges against the individual and assessing whether the government has met the burden of proof. This can involve disputing the factual basis of the charges, arguing for a different interpretation of the law, or presenting evidence that shows the individual is not removable.

What is removal defense?

V. Available Forms of Relief

Waivers and exceptions

Waivers and exceptions provide opportunities for individuals facing removal to request relief from certain grounds of removability. These may include waivers for unlawful presence, waivers for certain criminal convictions, or exceptions for humanitarian reasons.

Asylum and withholding of removal

Individuals who fear persecution or harm in their home country may be eligible to apply for asylum or withholding of removal. Asylum offers protection to those who can demonstrate a well-founded fear of persecution based on their race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group. Withholding of removal provides similar protection but with a higher burden of proof.

Cancellation of removal

Cancellation of removal is a form of relief available to certain non-permanent residents and lawful permanent residents who meet specific criteria. It allows individuals to request relief from removal and obtain lawful permanent resident status if they can demonstrate continuous physical presence, good moral character, and that their removal would result in exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to a qualifying relative.

Adjustment of status

In some cases, individuals in removal proceedings may be eligible to adjust their immigration status to become lawful permanent residents. This typically requires having an immediate family member who is a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident willing to petition on their behalf and meeting other eligibility requirements.

Voluntary departure

Voluntary departure provides an alternative to removal for individuals who agree to leave the country voluntarily within a specified period. It may offer certain benefits, such as the opportunity to apply for a visa or return to the United States legally in the future.

VI. Preparing for Removal Proceedings

Gathering evidence and documentation

In preparation for removal proceedings, it is crucial to gather all relevant evidence and documentation that can support the individual’s defense. This may include providing proof of family ties, employment history, community involvement, or evidence of rehabilitation if the individual has a criminal record.

Witness preparation

If there are witnesses who can provide testimony in support of the individual’s case, it is important to prepare them for the proceedings. This may involve conducting interviews, reviewing the facts of the case, and discussing the anticipated questions and answers.

Expert testimony

In some cases, expert testimony can be valuable in strengthening the individual’s defense. Experts in fields such as country conditions, trauma, or medical evaluations may provide professional opinions or analysis that can support the individual’s claims or challenge the government’s evidence.

Legal representation

Having qualified legal representation is crucial in removal proceedings. An experienced immigration attorney can provide guidance throughout the process, help gather the necessary evidence, prepare witnesses and expert testimony, and present a strong defense strategy.

Understanding the burden of proof

In removal proceedings, the burden of proof lies with the government. It is important to understand that the government must provide clear and convincing evidence to establish the individual’s removability. However, the individual also bears the responsibility of presenting evidence and arguments to challenge the government’s case and prove eligibility for relief.

VII. Navigating the Court Process

Master Calendar Hearing

The court process begins with a Master Calendar Hearing, where the immigration judge reviews the charges, addresses procedural matters, and sets the schedule for future hearings. During this hearing, the individual can enter a plea to the charges and request additional time to prepare their defense.

Individual Merits Hearing

The Individual Merits Hearing is the main hearing where the individual presents their case, evidence, and arguments to the immigration judge. Thisis an opportunity to challenge the government’s evidence, present witnesses, and provide legal arguments in support of the individual’s defense and eligibility for relief.

Presenting evidence and arguments

During the Individual Merits Hearing, the individual and their legal representation have the opportunity to present evidence and arguments to support their case. This may include testimonies, documents, expert opinions, or any other relevant evidence that can strengthen the individual’s defense.


Cross-examination is an essential part of the court process, where the government’s attorney may question the individual, their witnesses, or their expert witnesses. It is important to be prepared for cross-examination and work closely with legal counsel to anticipate potential questions and develop effective responses.

The judge’s decision

After considering all the evidence, arguments, and testimonies presented, the immigration judge will make a decision regarding the individual’s removability and eligibility for relief. The judge will issue a written decision explaining the reasons for their ruling, which may include granting relief, ordering removal, or other appropriate actions.

VIII. Post-Removal Proceedings

Appeals and motions to reopen

If an individual disagrees with the judge’s decision, they may have the option to file an appeal or a motion to reopen the case. Appeals are filed with the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) and are reviewed by a panel of judges. Motions to reopen are requests to the immigration judge to reconsider the case based on new evidence or legal arguments.

Voluntary departure options

If an individual is unable to obtain relief from removal, they may consider voluntary departure as an alternative to being forcibly removed. Voluntary departure allows individuals to leave the country voluntarily within a specified period, and it may have certain advantages, such as avoiding certain immigration penalties and preserving the possibility of returning to the United States legally in the future.

Immigration consequences of removal

Removal can have significant immigration consequences, including restrictions on reentry, ineligibility for certain forms of relief or future immigration benefits, and potential bars to admissibility. It is crucial to consult with an immigration attorney to fully understand the implications of removal and explore any available options for relief or protection.

Reentry after removal

If an individual has been removed from the United States, reentry can be challenging. Depending on the circumstances of their removal and any applicable bars to admissibility, they may need to wait for a specified period, obtain a waiver, or pursue other legal avenues to seek reentry.

Contact the Law Office of Ghenadie Rusu today to schedule a consultation and begin building your defense.

IX. Frequently Asked Questions

FAQ 1: Can I represent myself in removal proceedings?

Yes, individuals have the right to represent themselves in removal proceedings, but it is highly recommended to seek legal representation. Removal proceedings can be complex, and having an experienced immigration attorney can greatly improve the chances of a successful defense.

FAQ 2: What happens if I lose my removal case?

If an individual loses their removal case, they may have the option to file an appeal or a motion to reopen the case. It is important to consult with an immigration attorney to explore the available options based on the specific circumstances of the case.

FAQ 3: How long does the removal process take?

The duration of the removal process can vary significantly depending on various factors, such as the complexity of the case, court backlog, and availability of evidence. It is challenging to provide a precise timeline, but removal proceedings can take several months to several years to reach a resolution.

FAQ 4: Can I apply for relief while in removal proceedings?

Yes, individuals can apply for relief from removal while in proceedings. It is essential to consult with an immigration attorney to determine the most suitable forms of relief based on the individual’s circumstances and eligibility criteria.

FAQ 5: Is removal defense only for undocumentedimmigrants?

No, removal defense is not only for undocumented immigrants. It applies to both documented and undocumented individuals who are facing the risk of removal. Any non-U.S. citizen who is subject to removal proceedings has the right to present a defense and explore available options for relief or protection from deportation.

In conclusion, removal defense is a critical aspect of immigration law that helps individuals facing the risk of deportation navigate the complex legal process and seek relief from removal. By understanding the grounds for removal, the role of removal defense, and the various forms of relief available, individuals can effectively challenge their removability and explore potential avenues for remaining lawfully in the United States. It is essential to have qualified legal representation, gather relevant evidence, and be prepared for the court process to increase the chances of a successful defense. If you or someone you know is facing removal proceedings, consulting with an experienced immigration attorney is highly recommended to navigate this challenging process and protect your rights.

You might also enjoy

+1 (347) 907-1248

Mo-Fri 9am-6pm

Order a Free Consultation!

Fill out the form below and our lawyer will call you back